It is surprising that a Baptist preacher would write a book to expose the error of instrumental music in worship. John Price, who is a Baptist preacher, has provided an excellent work, Old Light on New Worship (Simpson Pub. Co. 2007). The book includes detailed reviews of Scripture and history regarding use of instruments in worship. His conclusion is firmly against the practice.
Other than footnote citations he makes no reference to a capella worship in churches of Christ, yet the form of his argumentation is very much parallel to the points we would make. Consider this paragraph on page 46:
The regulative principle of worship remains, and what God has not commanded in the New Testament we have no authority to use. He has not commanded the use of any musical instruments as he did in the days of Moses and David. Therefore, we have no authority to bring them into the worship of His church. The complete silence of the New Testament on musical instruments is a most compelling argument that they are not to exist in the church. Only singing is commanded (1 Cor. 14:15; Eph. 5:19; Col. 3:16).
It is especially noteworthy that the author comes to these conclusions in spite of having a religious background that continues to use instruments.
The author traces the historical evidence from the earliest post-apostolic writers down to the 20th Century. “The early Church Fathers were unanimous and vehement in condemning musical instruments in the worship of the church.” Further, he observed: “How can it possibly be assumed that musical instruments existed in the apostolic church when they were absent from the periods immediately prior and following?” Further, the book provides a large collections of quotations on the subject from centuries of theologians and commentators, including an appendix listing over two pages of names and groups who have opposed instrumental music in worship.
Mr. Price shares our disdain for what is advertised in worship in the modern setting.
In many worship services today, little difference can be found between a rock-and-roll concert and the music of the church. It was in the atmosphere of these musical instruments that the development of “Contemporary Christian Music” took place… (139).
A poisonous influence came out of the Richland Hills (TX) church when they announced their decision to include instrumental music in their worship. Their preacher, Rick Atchley, preached three sermons to argue that it is scriptural to worship either with or without the involvement of instruments. His arguments have been published abroad and apparently have given excuse for some liberal congregations to tilt farther to the left. Alan Highers in The Spiritual Sword and Dave Miller in his book, Richland Hills and Instrumental Music, published effective biblical responses to Atchley’s position. Another careful and thorough response is in the book by Thomas C. Alexander, Music in Worship (Gospel Advocate, 2010). Though all three of these capable brethren cover much of the same ground and hold the same conclusions, each of their presentations has its own special value.
Not many congregations in our area have been troubled by the strange doctrine called “Realized Eschatology” which, having been aggressively advocated by one Max King and his sympathizers, has devastated churches of Christ in other parts of the country. However, there are indications of its influence coming into the Carolinas. This is sometimes called “The 70 AD Theory” because of its contention that all Bible prophecy was fulfilled at the time of the Romans’ destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. This includes (according to the theory) even the second coming of Christ, the resurrection, judgment, and the end of the world. Yes, it is insisted that prophecies of the consummation of the world (as foretold in 2 Peter 3:10) were actually only the end of the Jewish system. To those not yet exposed to such extremities of interpretation, this might seem to fantastic to entertain. It happens, though, that by redefining terms and manipulating scriptures, the King movement has caught the fancy of some who are “unlearned and unstable” (2 Pet. 3:16). Two books by King set out his theory: The Spirit of Prophecy and The Cross and the Parousia of Christ. Other publications by King and his henchmen have continued its promotion.
I remember the late Burrell Prince’s reply when he was challenged to read King’s book. He was urged to read it all the way through. He said he had read enough to know he need not waste more time. He said, “If I get on a train and soon discover it is headed to the wrong destination, I don’t want to stay on it to the end of the line!” He had read enough to know the book was trying to take him in the wrong direction.*
For solid and clear refutation of the Max King doctrine, I recommend the book by Wayne Jackson, The A.D. 70 Theory (Courier Publications). Brother Jackson is always thorough and careful in his explanations. He shows the errors of false definitions of terms and inconsistencies in the appropriation of texts. It is a small book (just over 100 pages). It is needed anywhere there are issues related to Bible teaching on eschatology (“last things”).
Our brotherhood has been greatly blessed by Wayne Jackson’s writings on a wide variety of subjects.
While yet on the subject of books, perhaps it is acceptable for me to reference five of my own. Churches over the country and in other parts of the world continue to use The Beginning of our Confidence, lessons for new Christians (21st Century Pub.) It has been translated into four other languages. Thy Kingdom Come (Publishing Designs Co.) is a simple refutation of the errors of Premillennialism. It is in English and Russian. Many have used it privately and in classes for a simplified refutation of the more prominent errors of popular millennial theories.
A Happy Coincidence on a Desert Highway (Firm Foundation Pub.) is a collection of sermons. Modern Messages from the Minor Prophets (Quality Pub.) contains full sentence sermon outlines on all the Minor Prophets. These sermons seek to apply their Old Testament concerns to our current needs. It has also been translated into Russian.
Voices of Calvary (Publishing Designs Co.) has thirteen lessons on things Jesus and others said at the time of his crucifixion. Bible students know of the seven statements of Jesus from the cross. Each has a wealth of spiritual implications. In addition there are statements made by others at Calvary and each of these deserve more than a passing glance.
*Brother Prince was the first preacher in the church of Christ I ever heard. It was with what is now the Broad Street congregation in Statesville, NC. At the time they were meeting in the American Legion Building. In later years, when I was with the East Tennessee School of Preaching, we became closely associated with him and several times stayed in their home in Nashville.